Sunday, November 15, 2026

One of Bergoglio’s Greatest Critics Passed



Archbishop Hector Aguer, Jorge Mario Bergoglio's long-time opponent in Argentina, has passed away

The Archbishop Emeritus of La Plata, Msgr. Hector Aguer, passed away on November 10, 2026, at the age of 83. This was announced by the Archdiocese of La Plata in Argentina. With his passing, the Catholic Church loses one of its most prominent bishops in Latin America. Msgr. Aguer was not only a resolute defender of Catholic doctrine, but also of Church tradition. He was the inner-Argentine opponent of Jorge Mario Bergoglio, the later Pope Francis. Even after his retirement, he refused to be silenced.

Bergoglio's Opponent

Aguer and Bergoglio served simultaneously as auxiliary bishops of Buenos Aires in the 1990s under Cardinal Antonio Quarracino. While Bergoglio rose to become Quarracino's successor as Archbishop of Buenos Aires and thus Primate of Argentina, Aguer was appointed Coadjutor with right of succession in La Plata in 1998. From there, he led the non-Bergoglian minority in the Argentine episcopate in the following years, taking uncomfortable yet courageous steps as a defender of marriage, family, and life.

It remains a mystery why in 1997 Bergoglio and not Aguer was appointed Archbishop Coadjutor with right of succession for Buenos Aires by John Paul II, thereby preordaining his rise to the cardinalate and thus into the conclave, while Aguer remained the eternal number two in Argentina.

When Cardinal Bergoglio was elected Pope in 2013, the balance of power shifted significantly once again. Francis cleaned house with the conservative bishops who had gathered around Archbishop Aguer, gradually removing them from their offices. Msgr. Aguer himself remained Archbishop of La Plata, but only until his 75th birthday. Francis, always vindictive, utilized the age limit introduced as a post-conciliar innovation in canon law to exact retribution against his opponent.

A Slap in the Face on Departure: Victor Manuel Fernandez

On May 24, 2018, Aguer reached his 75th birthday and duly submitted his resignation. Francis accepted it as early as June 2. But that was not all: as his successor, he appointed none other than the controversial Victor Manuel Fernandez, nicknamed "Tucho," his closest theological confidant and ghostwriter.

This personnel decision was a demonstrative unkindness toward the departing archbishop. Fernandez was not only a staunch Bergoglian, but also embodied the very theological direction Aguer had opposed for years. To impose precisely this man upon him as a successor was tantamount to a public slap in the face. Furthermore, Francis refrained from keeping Aguer in office as diocesan administrator until his successor took over.

The appointment was an unmistakable signal: the Bergoglian course was now to prevail in La Plata as well.

Msgr. Fernandez was subsequently appointed Prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith by Francis in 2023. Thus, the man who had succeeded Aguer in La Plata rose to the very head of the former Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, was created a cardinal by Francis, and is now retained in office by Pope Leo XIV as well.

An Emeritus Who Did Not Remain Silent

With his retirement, however, Aguer by no means vanished from Church life. While many bishops become almost invisible after leaving office and exercise even greater restraint in public statements, Msgr. Aguer remained an uncomfortable admonisher. He criticized the ecclesiastical-political and theological developments under Francis and vigorously defended the Catholic transmission of faith. Msgr. Aguer also opposed the politicization trends under Francis.

This became particularly evident in his confrontation with the motu proprio Traditionis custodes of July 2021. With this document, Francis massively restricted the celebration of the traditional Roman rite. Msgr. Aguer disagreed decisively, describing Traditionis custodes as a "regrettable setback."

It is noteworthy that the archbishop himself had never celebrated the traditional Mass. He had been ordained a priest in 1972 according to the new Rite. His defense of the traditional liturgy thus stemmed not from personal preference, but from the conviction that the Church must not fight its own tradition.

He criticized the contradiction between the papal claim to promote the unity of the Church and a measure that placed precisely those faithful under pressure who held fast to the traditional liturgy.

A year later, his criticism became even sharper. Msgr. Aguer described the motu proprio as a "real disaster that forces priests and faithful into disobedience." He accused the Pope's inner circle of an "official progressivism" that disparaged traditional faithful while progressive currents were treated with leniency. Perhaps his most concise sentence was:

"The Pope is not the master of the liturgy who can do with it whatever he wants, but its servant and custodian."

Archbishop Aguer reminded people that the traditional liturgy is not a relic of an overcome past, but living Church tradition. Especially young people discovered in it solemnity, beauty, and reverence for the sacred that they frequently missed elsewhere.

An Uncomfortable Bishop Until the End

Msgr. Hector Aguer was a combative churchman who allowed himself to be intimidated neither by church-political power relations nor by personal headwinds. His path in life stands as an exemplary representation of the confrontation with the Bergoglian camp in the Argentine Church, a confrontation that Francis decided in his favor when making episcopal appointments.

Msgr. Aguer could have withdrawn after his retirement and taken note of the developments in Rome in silence. Yet he understood his episcopal office, even after stepping down from the leadership of the Archdiocese, as an obligation to stand up for the traditional faith.

As recently as July 2026, five years after the publication of Traditionis custodes, he again voiced sharp criticism of the papal document, lamenting that the restrictions had not healed the wounds, but deepened them. Interest in tradition and orthodoxy had grown, particularly among young people.

Thus, Msgr. Aguer remained an uncomfortable admonisher until his final months and a counter-image to those churchmen who arrange themselves with the respective power relations. And just one day before his death, he witnessed young Catholics in Buenos Aires drawing attention to their request with several actions, asking for unrestricted freedom to be restored to the Immemorial Rite and tradition.

With his death on November 10, 2026, the life of a bishop comes to an end who refused to be bent or silenced.

Requiem aeternam dona ei, Domine, et lux perpetua luceat ei.

Text: Giuseppe Nardi Image: Wikicommons/Katholisches.info

Trans: Tancred vekron99@hotmail.com

AMDG


No comments: