Wednesday, May 10, 2017

SSPX -- A Question of Papal Heresy

[SSPX USA] This final section of Part 6 of Fr. Gleize’s precise study of whether or not a heretical pope loses his investiture must be read in the light of the previous sections.
The author of this series, Fr. Jean-Michel Gleize, has been a professor in the SSPX's Seminary of St. Pius X in Econe, Switzerland for 20 years, where he is currently teaching ecclesiology. He is the author of numerous articles in Courrier de Rome and is a consultant to the SSPX commission responsible for doctrinal discussions with the Holy See.

Editor’s Note

This final section of Part 6 of Fr. Gleize’s precise study of whether or not a heretical pope loses his investiture must be read in the light of the previous sections. This section closes out Fr. Gleize’s critical analysis of the various speculative approaches to the issue of the papacy and heresy.

Part 6c – Does a pope who falls into heresy lose his investiture in the Primacy?

Comments on Using St. Clement as an Authority

The new explanation of Fr. Devillers presented earlier is untenable. First of all because the argument from authority that it invokes is nonexistent. In the passage quoted from the Epistle to the Corinthians, St. Clement does not maintain any of the assertions that are attributed to him by Fr. Devillers (see Part 6a).


nazareusrex said...

El caso de Bergoglio es diferente porque Bergoglio ya era un hereje formal en Argentina que había sido denunciado por herejía en el 2010 incluso en un libro por el Profesor Antonio Caponnetto y denunciado por colaborar con el marxismo, por promover la herejía judaizante, el indiferentismo religioso, también permitió las comuniones sacrílegas a los gay y adúlteros, por su afiliación al club rotario masónico, etc. Quedando con ello varias veces excomulgado Ipso Facto.
Y el Magisterio de la Iglesia enseña que un hereje esta imposibilitado para ser papa porque no pertenece a la Iglesia.

N.D. said...

Prior to being elected pope, Jorge Bergoglio condoned certain same-sex sexual relationships as long as they were, according to Jorge Bergoglio, private, did not include children, and were not called marriage.

By condonng certain same-sex sexual relationships, and thus same-sex sexual acts, Jorge Bergoglio, prior to his election, denied the Sanctity of the marital act.

By denying the Sanctity of the marital act, Jorge Bergoglio, denied that God, The Most Holy And Undivided Blessed Trinity, Is The Author of Love, of Life, and of Marriage, and thus denied Salvational Love, God's Gift of Grace and Mercy, which is an act of apostasy that separates oneself from Christ, and thus Christ's One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church.

An apostate cannot be a validly elected Pope; a Catholic must be in communion with Christ and His One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church.

JBQ said...

In 2015, I attended the March 16 evening dinner for the St. Patrick's Day Parade at the NY Athletic Club. Timothy Cardinal Dolan was the grand marshal and I trekked from St. Louis to support this native son. It was related in talk that Dolan was pressured from Rome to support the inclusion of a gay group in the 6 hour march. Dolan has admitted that Francis personally intervened. The unknown is that in a private message that Cardinal Dolan was also told "to keep an open mind" about gay marriage. The question is now burgeoning of whether the handmaiden of gay marriage which is abortion will attend the marriage of the socialist melding of modern truth.