Saturday, August 24, 2013

Criticism of Pope Francis From the USA -- "Pope Maker" Dolan: Absence of Managerial Skills and Leadership Skills



(New York) The North American bishops, it they were heard just after the Conclave last March, were decisive for the election of Pope Francis. Although they were not the "forgers" of the new pontificate, but their voices and their weight were ultimately decisive. Just from the United States, there now comes the first direct and surprisingly harsh criticism of Pope Francis. Expression of this is found in an interviews of the Archbishop of New York and chairman of the U.S. Bishops Conference, Cardinal Timothy Dolan and Archbishop of Philadelphia, Charles Chaput. Cardinal Dolan talks about a "lack of managerial and leadership quality," Cardinal Chaput of a certain dissatisfaction with the election of Cardinal Bergoglio among the circles of faithful Catholics toward the Pope.

Several cardinals of the United States were considered "papabili". However, in a joint statement just before start of the Conclave, a novelty, they announced their collective rejection, founded on the unexpected withdrawal because of possible "damage" to the Church, as an American pope could in other parts of the world result in inappropriate identification of the Church, or completely, of Christianity with the world power USA.

American "Pope Maker" First Critic of Pope Francis

Accordingly, the American media celebrated the New York Archbishop Timothy Dolan Cardinal on his return to the conclave, as "Pope Maker". Cardinal Dolan is not the "creator" of the candidacy of his Argentine confrere. This is enough already back in the conclave in 2005. The actual promoters were known as Cardinal Martini 2005 and in 2013, Cardinal Lehmann, to name just two. In contrast to the penultimate Conclave of 2013, the alliance was much broader. Overcoming a two-thirds majority in an election without strong candidates or favorites is no easy task. Cardinal Dolan was considered the "Pope Maker" because the pivoting of the North American Pope voters (at least the majority), ultimately brought the decisive turning point in the conclave to the Argentine.

Well, surprisingly, criticism of Pope Francis comes straight from the U.S.. It is the first clear vocal criticism because so far the Cardinals and local churches had at least appeared to be carried away by the media cheering for the new pontificate. Cheering, which must not be forgotten, was especially one last scold of Pope Benedict XVI. The published opinion presented of the Church in a way as an acclamation, as a Pope had not in any case ever been. The reaction was inevitable: Francis Pope turns out to be quite the deliberate contrast to Pope Benedict XVI, as a connoisseur of amazing acts corresponding to media psychology and media-friendly.. The German-speaking bishops are more in the media's grip, as recently showed the incident in Würzburg seminary. There has only been a bishop who is not under the media's under control: the St. Pölten's Bishop Kurt Krenn. Bishop Krenn used his media fluency to convey Catholic doctrine, where his brother bishops were sometimes rather silent. For this he is not cheered in the media. Rather, he was their favorite bogeyman, but they could neither diminish his bravery in handling media or his intellectual stature. Whether Pope Francis will succeed in this. So far, the media cheering has exhausted itself more on trivialities of modern media icons, as they produce show business, sports, and sometimes even politics.

Cardinal Dolan has "seen little" of "Managerial Skills and Leadership Qualities" so Far

The criticism from the United States is therefore a remarkable indicator of the papacy begun in March. Cardinal Dolan brought them out in an interview with John Allen, a Vaticanist for the Old Liberal National Catholic Reporter. He was personally very direct, limited to specific issues, but more on a seemingly technical aspects, but this is only at first glance. "We also wanted someone with good managerial skills and leadership quality, and until now, little has been seen of it." With these words, the New York Archbishop described the pontificate of Pope Francis till then. One could speak of a frontal criticism. Cardinal Dolan has expressed his criticism already a few weeks ago on the brink of World Youth Day in Rio de Janeiro. The National Catholic Reporter published the Inteview on the 24th of July on the internet.

Nearly five months after the election of a pope one of the key figures of the conclave declared that Pope Francis has not been sufficiently a "manager" and not enough of a "leader". A Pope must be a "manager", he should have "leadership".

Cardinal Dolan: After Summer Break He is Finally to Appoint a New Secretary of State

In his concrete criticism, Cardinal Dolan limited himself to the occupation of the State Secretariat, continuing on to the top of the Roman Curia and the same under Pope Francis. On the eve of the conclave, dismissal of Secretary of State Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone was loudly called for by various parties. Cardinal Bertone was among the most important employees of Pope Benedict XVI. in the governance of the Church. He was not unjustly blamed for many mishaps that made the German Pope and his many opponents within the church a target of the media enjoyment for persistent accusation.

Cardinal Dolan then said he expects a change at the top of the State Secretariat before the summer break. And further: "I expect that concrete after the summer break a more concrete signal towards changing the administration."

Archbishop Chaput: Some Dissatisfaction with Election of Pope Francis Faithful Circles

The criticism by the President of the U.S. bishops' conference does not go beyond that. He remained therefore open to where and how criticism would appear from other American bishops to the official leadership of Pope Francis. At the same time, however, it was loud and slightly accentuated. To make the point he brought up the Archbishop of Philadelphia, Charles Chaput, the cardinal contender when his predecessor Cardinal Justin Francis Rigali reached his attained age of 80 in April of 2015. Archbishop Chaput, one of the most important American church leaders, is considered to be faithful and connected to tradition. He expressed also in an interview with the National Catholic Reporter , "a certain dissatisfaction" over the election of Cardinal Bergoglio to Pope, which was particularly noticeable among the faithful, loyal to Rome.

Cardinal Dolan did not take up the criticism of conservative or traditionally associated parts of the Church, about about liturgical changes by Pope Francis, the controversial "style" of the Pope, a certain ambivalence of the Pope to the major bioethical challenges of our time, homosexuality and the aggressive gender ideology. Cardinal Dolan was limited in his criticism on the issue of the "Leadership of Office". The Vatican expert Andrea Tornielli says that behind, a "typical American concern" hides: the call for efficient "managers". But that is likely to fall short. Cardinal Dolan is president of the Bishops' Conference, he measured his criticism well, considered and limited to one aspect of the risk of no special media attention, but this is directed toward the Pope in Rome.

Zeal For Action in Vatican bank - for incidental Catholic Church

Pope Francis Pope has shown zeal to date, especially in the context of the Vatican bank IOR and the Economic Affairs of the Holy See. That got a lot of applause, regarding the downright legendary banking institution. The use astonishment: the botched appointment of a personal representative in the person of the controversial Bishop Battista Ricca, the appointment of three commissions for the control and monitoring of the bank, of which at least one was but then too much occupied and another are seemingly doubtful reshuffles at the top of the foundation and finally a private motu proprio with some new rules. The Vatican Bank according to some conspiracy theorists who may have some beads of sweat on their foreheads and also some church enemies who dream of "legendary" riches of the Church. In reality, the bank is considered to be at 10 billion euros on their deposits, in international comparison, a small bank. Apportioned to the number of Catholics worldwide, there are just six or seven euros in the bank from each. Financial and economic matters are now but not really the most important affairs of the Catholic Church, not even the second most important, which is why this whole effort has but surprised some observers.

Only John Paul II Appointed a Secretary immediately - Progressive Disillusionment

Cardinal Bertone, focused on the criticism of Cardinal Dolan to Pope Francis, will be 79 in December. A change is therefore coming 0one way or another. No pope has ever exchanged the Cardinal Secretary of State immediately after his election. There are other rhythms in the Church. Pope Pius XII. appointed none. As former Secretary of State, the Pope was his own Secretary of State. Pope Paul VI. kept to his predecessor from John XXIII. "Inherited" for six years. John Paul I did not make any personnel decisions due to his unexpected death. Only John Paul II appointed a new Secretary of State within a few months. However, Cardinal Jean Villot had died. Pope Paul VI took over, five months after the beginning of pontificate, so probably a quick dismissal of the French bearer and Council Secretary of the Polish Pope must remain speculation.

As a Jesuit Pope Francis takes the time necessary to make an informed decisions. He looking for his information and then decides alone. This is evidenced by his adherence to the appointment of Msgr Ricca for domestic prelates of the Vatican Bank, despite becoming known by his explosive and inglorious past. Previous decisions can not be returned. What are the announced in the media and emphasized by many cardinals who resided diocesan bishops demanded reform of the Curia is concerned, you will have to wait for the first meeting of the new eight-member council of Cardinals. The meeting is scheduled for early October. In progressive circles, after the initial euphoria, there is a slogan, not to place too high expectations for the new pontificate. The progressive religious women were the first who waved the Jubilee flags.

Text: Giuseppe Nardi
 Image: Tempi
Trans: Tancred vekron99@hotmail.com
AMGD

17 comments:

Anonymous said...

I think the hierarchy should shut-up and not anticipate the Pope publicly. What has Cardinal Dolan done to manage and clean up his charge? Does he raise a lot of money? Does he do anything else?

Anonymous said...

I think this Pope realizes that he's not going to be around for a long time, so he might not feel compeled to change much. Many of his appointments have been bad ones....Ricca for instance.
He's going to be 77, and has a lot more wrong with him than Benedict XVI did at 77.
One thing I read about him I don't like, however. That is that in living alone in that little house rather than the Vatican, he has surrounded himself with a bunch of like minded people....and some of the names being floated abround by them for Vatican appointments are radical liberals (Darmuid Martin of Dublin being one of them).
If he does replace the present worthless crew in the Vatican (mostly JP II men used by Benedict XVI), with radicals, I think I'll switch to the Greek Orthodox Church.
To be honest, I have not liked Pope Francis I from the very first moment, when he came out onto the balcony of St. Peter's after his election in such a departure from tradition. He has done nothing to change my mind.
He won't be around long, but I hope the next Pope cleans up the mess, and reverses Francis' innovations and proclivities post haste!

Amateur Brain Surgeon said...

Only a Prelate like Dolan would be brash enough to criticise other Prelates for poor management and poor leadership skills when his own record is so poor.

Hey, Timothy Cardinal Dolan, who not a few more photos of your self guffawing with the jug-eared Mahometan, Barack Hussein Obama?

That is leadership, baby.

I'd like the criticism to come from a Traditionalist who wears the Galero - sadly, there are none of those

Tancred said...

There are more radicals in Orthodoxy than in the Real Church. Liturgy is no guarantee against heresy.

Aged parent said...

Having lived under the "leadership" of Dolan when he was in Milwaukee I find it hilarious that he should be criticizing the Pope in this matter. It's a little like the pot calling the kettle black.

When he was here in Milwaukee he had plenty of opportunities to clean up the filthy mess left by Weakland but he did exactly nothing in that regard. He's nothing but a mere politician in every bad sense of that term.

The Vatican must really hate Milwaukee because they have given us mediocrities like Dolan and now Listecki, or creeps like Weakland.

Anonymous said...

The only "skills" needed by a pope are missionary skills.

Anonymous said...

not Spartacus, I'm Anon above ad that's precisely what I meant. Right now we have the Smiling Pope but at least we don't have the Guffawing Pope.

Anonymous said...

What do you mean by that Tancred? Can you give an example? I'm not challenging you, I just wonder what you mean by that.

Anonymous said...

+Timo, Archbishop of Gotham, is a treacherous fellow. He always thought he was the king of baby-kissers and now the bishop of Rome is topping him. New York is not the capitol of the world, St. Patrick Cathedral is not America's parish church. He is a self-promoting, glad-handing, grandstanding, devious careerist. He was found to not have a photo of Francis in his residence months after his election; +Timo is now thinking the pope's simpler lifestyle may have something to do with him in his Park Avenue Palace. Dolan see himself as a hyper-moral person, incapable of arrogance or pomposity. His career will end in NYC, so he'd better become more of a pastor than an pietistic palaverer.

Anonymous said...

+Timo, Archbishop of Gotham, is a treacherous fellow. He always thought he was the king of baby-kissers and now the bishop of Rome is topping him. New York is not the capitol of the world, St. Patrick Cathedral is not America's parish church. He is a self-promoting, glad-handing, grandstanding, devious careerist. He was found to not have a photo of Francis in his residence months after his election; +Timo is now thinking the pope's simpler lifestyle may have something to do with him in his Park Avenue Palace. Dolan see himself as a hyper-moral person, incapable of arrogance or pomposity. His career will end in NYC, so he'd better become more of a pastor than an pietistic palaverer.

Anonymous said...

What anybody sees in Timothy Dolan to promote him to where he is today is beyond me. He serves one person, and one person only, himself. He came to Milwaukee on the heals of the Weakland scandal and left everyone in place, as did his successor, Archbishop Listecki. It is beyond comprehension that Milwaukee still has the same administration from the days of Weakland. It is said that Dolan's promoter is the now Cardinal Harvey, a Milwaukee native. Harvey should have had more concern and more mercy on his hometown and home archdiocese.

Tancred said...

The OCA and even ROCOR has a lot of the same problems as we do. There are all kinds of Marxists and sexual deviants in Orthodox clergy, but there's a cosmetic cover that obscures these problems for an outsider, as well as an imaginary unity.

Anonymous said...

Are you serious about Park Avenue? If so possibly something needs to be done about this seeming outrage.

Amos said...

Everything you stated is exactly why he is where he is. No mystery at all.

Lynda said...

I was again disappointed (but not surprised) by Cardinal Dolan when he was in Ireland recently and said nothing about the most evil legislation ever purported to be passed in this jurisdiction and what it must mean for Catholics who brought about this provision for the systematic and public killIng of children prior to birth, and for those who support and enable this abomination.

Hurry, Lord or we perish! said...

Maybe Dolan was right? :(((

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/religion/the-pope/10276319/Pope-breaks-with-protocol-by-bowing-to-Queen-Rania-of-Jordan.html

Hughie said...

“No pope has ever exchanged the Cardinal Secretary of State immediately after his election. There are other rhythms in the Church. Pope Pius XII appointed none. As former Secretary of State, the Pope was his own Secretary of State.”

Totally wrong on both counts.

As far as Pope Pius XII is concerned, he was elected on March 2, 1939. On March 10, two days before his coronation, pressed by the French cardinals (whose votes are said to have been decisive for his election) he named Luigi Cardinal Maglione as his Cardinal Secretary of State. Consecrated bishop and provided as archbishop to the titular See of Caesarea in Palestrina upon his appointment as Apostolic Nuncio to Switzerland in 1920 (aged 43 years), on June 23, 1926 he was transferred to France. Ten years later, on June 18, 1936 he was created cardinal in the title of Santa Pudenziana and so had to resign as Nuncio. He was appointed Cardinal Prefect of the Council (now the Congregation for the Clergy) on July 22, 1938.

If you look at the history of the Popes/Cardinal Secretaries of State you find that it was only when you come to the transition from Pope Benedict XV to Pope Pius XI in 1922 that a newly elected Pope retained the services of his predecessor’s Cardinal Secretary of State, in this case Pietro Cardinal Gasparri.

If we start at 1800, Pope Pius VII/Ercole Cardinal Consalvi;
Leo XII/Tommaso Cardinal Bernetti; Pius VIII/Giuseppe Andrea Cardinal Albani; Gregory XVI/Tommaso Cardinal Bernetti/ Luigi Emmanuele Nicolo Cardinal Lambruschini; Pius XI/ Tommaso Pasquale Cardinal Gizzi/Gabriele Cardinal Ferretti/ Giovanni Cardinal Soglia Ceroni; Pope Leo XII/Alessandro Cardinal Franchi/Lorenzo Cardinal Nina/Lodovico Cardinal Jacobini/Mariano Cardinal Rampolla del Tindaro; Pope Pius X/ Archbishop Rafael Merry del Val y Zulueta (President of the Pontifical Ecclesiastical Academy who had been drafted in as Secretary of the Conclave at the last minute due to the sudden death of the prelate who should have been the Secretary) as Pro-Secretary before creating him Cardinal Priest in the title of Santa Pressede aged a mere 38 years on November 12 following; on which date he became Cardinal Secretary of State.

I hope this clarifies matters.